Review - The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin

Friday August 30, 1996

Theatre

The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin by Steve J. Spears.  

Ian Croker, directed by Colin Anderson, 

at Cafe Thespia, Jamison ACT.  

Professional.

Opening night, Wednesday August 28, 1996

Reviewed by Frank McKone

"In retrospect, the performance as well as the production by Richard Wherrett probably lulled most of us into overpraising the play when it first appeared. Nonetheless it was a triumphant success on three continents."  (Leonard Radic in The State of Play, 1991).  

In Colin Anderson's production there is the same tension between, on the one hand, an immediate audience response to the one-liners, the visuals (including nudity) and the sound effects (everyone appreciates why Robert O'Brien blasts the cuckoo clock) and, on the other, a niggling concern about the artistic truth and (after 20 years) the relevance of the play.

Laughter abounds through the first two acts, but the final act is only a partial success unless the ever-present sense of danger can be built up from the opening line of the play.  In 1976 the likelihood of homosexual men being murdered was public knowledge, and Spears tried genuinely to re-cast the image of transvestites: O'Brien falls in love with the 12 year old Benjamin but does not act out his sexual fantasy.  But I think Spears missed the point.  The one-liners make the character superficially attractive, but O'Brien holds back not on moral grounds but only because he knows he will be destroyed if the relationship is made public.

Probably this play helped change attitudes even so: now we have the Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras and gay rights are better entrenched in law.  However, gay bashing is still common.  On the other hand the World Congress on the Sexual Exploitation of Children currently in Stockholm would show that today Benjamin Franklin, though a 12 year old seducer of middle aged men, is a victim of a "global, multi-billion-dollar industry" (Carol Bellamy, executive director of UNICEF).  I think Spears was ultimately naive in his comic presentation of Robert O'Brien and the play's popularity for a few years in Australia, London, San Francisco and New York is not a measure of its worth in the long run.

Though you will have a convivial night at Cafe Thespia, and between laughing you will sympathise with Robert, and think about the issues, The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin did its bit 20 years ago.  It's hooked to the Skyhooks and the young Mick Jagger, and though it is interesting historically to see a revival, I think it is better to leave it pegged in its place and time.

©Frank McKone, Canberra

First published in The Canberra Times, Friday August 30, 1996

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Monday September 2, 1996

‘Franklin’ review an insult to actor

Frank McKone’s review (CT, August 30, p.13) of Steve J. Spear’s play The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin, starring Ian Croker and directed by Colin Anderson, is an insult to professional theatre and particularly Mr Croker.

The actor is not mentioned once during the review, nor is there any criticism offered of his performance which, considering the play has a cast of one, leaves me almost speechless.

I don’t know what the arts department is up to at The Canberra Times, but offering an irrelevant piece of journalism like that in a national newspaper is an embarrassment to us all.

TONY MAGEE

Torrens